DOL's proposed PERM rule: What employers need to know
On Tuesday, the U.S. Department of Labor published a proposed rule that would be the first major rewrite of the PERM labor certification rules in about two decades, as Daniel Ball previously reported.
PERM, the Permanent Labor Certification Program, is the labor market test that employers must complete before sponsoring most foreign nationals for EB-2 and EB-3 green cards. The public notice and comment period for the proposed rule runs 60 days from publication, ending January 19, 2027. Current rules stay in effect until a final rule takes effect.
An in-depth analysis of the proposed rule is available here.
Key changes for employers
Recruitment
The DOL would replace the current rules with a single standard for all occupations.
- Required steps. The employer would be required to post a job order with each State Workforce Agency serving the place of employment, an advertisement on the employer's business websites, an advertisement on at least one outside job search website, and social media advertising where the employer customarily uses it for the occupation. In addition, the employer would be required to participate in at least one job fair, on-campus event, or school placement office listing. Mandatory print ads and the menu of optional steps would be eliminated.
- Duration and timing. Ads would be required to run at least 90 days, or longer if the employer customarily advertises comparable non-PERM jobs for more than 90 days. Recruitment would have to end 30 to 60 days before filing, and the application would have to be filed within 30 days after recruitment ends. In practice, recruitment would start at least about four months before filing, after the prevailing wage determination is in hand.
- Consistency with ordinary hiring practices. Recruitment would have to use the same channels, locations, and application methods that the employer uses for comparable non-PERM roles. PERM-specific email addresses or paper-only applications would be presumed not to be in good faith. Interviews would have to be available by phone or video, and applicant tracking systems must capture and keep searchable every PERM applicant. Ads would be required to state the wage, duties, requirements, work location (including remote or hybrid), and number of openings.
- Job requirements. Requirements would have to be normal for the occupation. The DOL may compare them to the employer's non-PERM postings from the prior 12 months. Materially stricter requirements would have to be justified by business necessity.
Layoffs and third-party placements
- Two-year layoff bar. No PERM filing would be accepted if the employer laid off U.S. workers in the same or a similar occupation (same Standard Occupational Classification code, or a position sharing at least 51 percent of the duties) in the area of intended employment during the prior two years. A "layoff" is any involuntary separation without cause, including a reduction in force or restructuring.
- After filing. Until the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services made a decision on the Form I-140 immigrant petition, any layoff of U.S. workers would have to be reported to the DOL (and the USCIS, if an I-140 petition is pending) within five business days. The employer would also be required to offer the job to the laid-off U.S. workers at the same wage and under the same terms, and update its recruitment report. The proposed rule sets no method or deadline for making the offer.
- Placements at other companies. The employer could not place the employee with another employer (or its affiliates) that has laid off U.S. workers in a similar occupation during the same period, where there are indicia of an employment relationship, such as control over the work, tools, hours, and location. Notice of filing would have to be posted at client sites. A new condition in the definition of "permanent employment" would bar temporary staffing agreements that place the employee with third-party clients, a term the proposal does not define.
Schedule A, remote work, and place of employment
- Schedule A eliminated. Employers sponsoring nurses, physical therapists, or individuals of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts could no longer skip recruitment and file directly with the USCIS. They would have to complete full PERM, and exceptional-ability cases would face the "equally qualified" standard, under which a U.S. applicant at least as qualified as the foreign national counts as available.
- Remote and roving roles. The DOL describes possible new approaches (the nearest employer office for roving roles, the employee's location for remote roles) and asks whether fully remote positions should be eligible at all. These ideas are not yet in the proposed regulatory text.
Records, notice, and attestations
- Records with every filing. The recruitment report, ads, and all U.S. applicant resumes would be submitted with the application. The report would be required to list each ad's URL and confirmation number, each applicant's disposition, and who screened each applicant. Incomplete filings would be returned unprocessed, with no appeal.
- Longer notice of filing. The notice would be posted within 10 business days before filing and stay up until USCIS makes a decision on the I-140 petition, in at least two conspicuous locations or electronically, and at third-party worksites.
- Expanded attestations. Under penalty of perjury, the employer would attest that the job stays open to qualified U.S. workers through the I-140 decision; that U.S. workers, including current employees in similar positions, receive terms no less favorable than the foreign national; that the employer can pay the wage from existing, non-contingent resources; and that the employer complies with Title VII, 8 U.S.C. § 1324b, and the Fair Labor Standards Act. The employer must sign every submission.
Enforcement and process
- Enforcement. Audit and supervised recruitment findings may be shared with the U.S. Department of Justice, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Department of Homeland Security, and the DOL Inspector General. Debarment of up to three years would extend to all DOL labor certification and labor condition programs, including H-1B. Attorneys, agents, and successors in interest could be debarred as well.
- Filing mechanics. Electronic filing would be mandatory, and the prevailing wage determination would have to come before recruitment. A certification would support only one initial I-140 petition, and records must be kept for five years after the USCIS decision.
- Costs. The DOL estimates that the rule would save employers about $164 million a year, almost entirely from dropping print ads. It does not quantify the cost of the layoff bar, post-filing monitoring and reporting, or longer timelines.
Timing
Comments are due January 19, 2027, and you can submit comments here. A final rule could take effect as soon as 60 days after publication, with a 30-day transition: applications and PWD requests filed on or after day 90 would follow the new rules, and earlier filings would follow the current rules.
What to do now
Employers should take the following steps now:
- Identify recent and planned layoffs by occupation and location.
- Review how sponsored roles are advertised, including applicant tracking settings.
- Flag remote, roving, and client-site roles.
- Sort pending and planned cases by when they would be filed.
- Consider submitting comments.
If you have any questions or would like to discuss, please contact any member of our Immigration Practice Group.
Current rule versus proposed rule
| Topic | Current rule | Proposed rule |
|---|---|---|
| Required recruitment | 30-day job order and two Sunday print ads; professional roles add three steps chosen from a list of 10 | Job order(s), employer website(s), one outside job site, social media if customary, and one job fair, campus event, or placement office listing; no print requirement |
| Duration | 30-day job order; no minimum for other steps | At least 90 days for the first four methods, or the employer's customary period for comparable non-PERM jobs if longer |
| Timing | Recruitment within the 180 days before filing, with mandatory steps at least 30 days before | Recruitment finished 30 to 60 days before filing; application filed within 30 days after recruitment ends |
| Comparison to non-PERM hiring | Good-faith attestation; no express comparability requirement | Same channels, locations, application methods, and duration as comparable non-PERM roles; applicant tracking system must capture PERM applicants; virtual interviews |
| Recruitment records | Retained by the employer; submitted only on audit or request | Submitted with every application, including a detailed recruitment report and all U.S. applicant resumes |
| Layoffs | Layoff in the area within 6 months before filing triggers a duty to notify and consider laid-off workers | Filing barred after a layoff of U.S. workers in the same or similar occupation within 2 years; after filing, report within 5 business days, offer the job, and update the report |
| Third-party placements | Not specifically addressed | No placement with an employer that has had similar layoffs; notice at third-party worksites; new "temporary staffing agreement" condition |
| Notice of filing | Posted for 10 consecutive business days, 30 to 180 days before filing | Posted within 10 business days before filing and kept up until USCIS decides the I-140 petition; two locations or electronic posting; third-party worksites; bargaining representatives at all places of employment |
| Schedule A | Nurses, physical therapists, and exceptional-ability cases skip recruitment and file with USCIS | Eliminated; full PERM, with an "equally qualified" standard for exceptional ability |
| Remote and roving work | 1994 guidance: "various unanticipated locations" plus headquarters address; full address for remote roles | Preamble describes new approaches (nearest office for roving; employee's city, county, ZIP code, and BLS area for remote) and asks whether to exclude fully remote roles |
| Attestations and signatures | Attestations on the application form; employer signs the application and report | Expanded attestations under penalty of perjury, including U.S. worker parity and job openness until USCIS decides the I-140 petition; employer signs every submission |
| Debarment | Up to 3 years from PERM | Up to 3 years across all DOL labor certification and labor condition application programs, including H-1B; new grounds; attorneys, agents, and successors can be debarred; DOL asks about 5 or 10 years |
| Certification and records | Valid 180 days to file the I-140 petition; some employers reuse it after a denial; records kept 5 years from filing | Supports one initial I-140 petition only; records kept 5 years from the USCIS decision |
| Filing and prevailing wage | Electronic filing not mandated; incomplete applications denied; recruitment may begin before the PWD is obtained | Mandatory electronic filing; incomplete applications returned and not appealable; PWD required before recruitment begins; redetermination step eliminated; duplicate requests for the same job opportunity and area in a wage year returned |
| Effective date | Not applicable | 60-day delayed effective date plus 30-day transition; applications filed on or after day 90 follow the new rule |