A strikeout for everyone.
The current collective bargaining agreement between Major League Baseball and the Major League Baseball Players Association expires at midnight on December 1. According to Kalshi, a prediction market, the chances that the parties will reach an agreement by that date are 5 percent.
Assuming no agreement, it is nearly certain that MLB and its 30 clubs will lock out the players – refusing to permit them to work and also withholding their pay – as part of a renewed effort to impose a salary cap.
That effort, like past ones, is likely to fail.
1994 revisited
Comparisons between the upcoming labor stoppage and the 1994 players’ strike will abound. There are important similarities and differences.
First, the 1994 strike was also largely about the league’s efforts to impose a salary cap, among other changes to players’ pay and free agency and salary arbitration rights.
However, in 1994, the work stoppage was initiated by the players. The 1990 contract expired shortly after the conclusion of the 1993 season, but the clubs permitted the players to play in 1994 under the terms of the expired contract. The players voted to strike – and, in the process, missed the first World Series in 90 years – because they believed appropriate progress had not been made on negotiations for a new agreement.
MLB’s failure to obtain a salary cap at that time came down to two principal factors: (1) legal mistakes, and (2) Don Fehr and the history of the Players Association.
As for legal mistakes, MLB and its clubs had undermined much goodwill by having colluded during the 1980s. Teams actively communicated and conspired to suppress competition for players and players’ salaries. The union won several grievances over this issue before MLB agreed to pay $280 million to the players in 1990.
Then, in December 1994, MLB declared an impasse in the negotiations and attempted to unilaterally impose new terms of employment. These terms included a salary cap, and the elimination of free agency, salary arbitration, and the anti-collusion provision of the contract.
The National Labor Relations Board filed suit seeking an injunction against MLB on the ground that its actions constituted an unfair labor practice.
In an April 3, 1995 decision, Sonia Sotomayor, then a judge in the Southern District of New York, agreed and granted the injunction. Judge Sotomayor agreed with the Board that MLB had failed to negotiate in good faith with the players about mandatory subjects of bargaining. Per Judge Sotomayor’s order, the 1990 contract was restored.
The 1995 season began on April 25. Eventually, the parties agreed to a new contract in 1996 that did not include a salary cap.
The players stood strong based on decades of solidarity. Marvin Miller famously led the players through litigation that saw the end of the reserve clause in the 1970s and negotiations that resulted in much of baseball’s current system. The Players Association did so despite arguments by the league that eliminating the reserve clause would destroy the sport (a common argument by all leagues at the time).
Don Fehr had worked on the famous Andy Messersmith/Dave McNally arbitration, which effectively ended the reserve clause. Mr. Miller hired Mr. Fehr as general counsel for the Players Association in 1977. He took over as Executive Director on an interim basis in 1983 and formally in 1985.
Mr. Fehr and his staff held the players together to resist the owners’ demands, in part by relying on the union’s history.
Déjà vu all over again
The league and players have managed to reach new agreements ever since without missing games, though the 2022 season was delayed due to a lockout.
Now, however, MLB has decided that it is time go all in on a salary cap, reportedly refusing to negotiate any contract that does not include one. The league’s principal stated reason is to enhance competitive balance by improving the financial performance and competitiveness of smaller market teams. MLB, the union, and pundits of various kinds all have statistics that they claim support their position on the issue.
Bruce Meyer, the interim Executive Director for the Players Association, believes the league wants a salary cap principally to suppress player pay, and to increase the clubs’ profits and thus also their franchise valuations. Indeed, franchise valuations across sports have been increasing at exponential rates in recent years.
Before the 2026 season, Sportico estimated that the average MLB club was worth $3.17 billion and had revenues of approximately $436 million. However, the rate of increase has been slower than in other sports leagues.
Fan sentiment appears mixed. In a recent poll conducted by Sports Business Journal and Seton Hall University, 54 percent of baseball fans said they supported a salary cap. (Hardly a home run endorsement.) Moreover, in the event of a work stoppage, 39 percent said they would blame the owners while only 20 percent said they would blame the players. The percentage who said they would blame “neither” (although “both” may be a better interpretation) was 33 percent.
Swing and a miss
MLB’s efforts are likely to fail once again. The economic and competitive arguments for the proposed cap are questionable. Fans, too, seem to be skeptical.
The league undoubtedly hopes that missed games and pay will impose enough financial pain on the players to drive them to agree to the proposal.
But the union arguably has the stiffer backbone.
To that point, Mr. Meyer is the perfect person to lead the Players Association at this time. He has a remarkable 40-year career of representing professional athletes in collective bargaining negotiations and related litigation. If there were a sports lawyers hall of fame, he would be in it. He is unlikely to recommend that the Players Association, one of the strongest unions in the country, give up its decades-long opposition to a salary cap.
For similar reasons, it would be surprising if players decided to decertify the union as their bargaining representative for the purpose of pursuing antitrust litigation against MLB. Mr. Meyer was involved in several such efforts on behalf of players in the National Football League and the National Basketball Association, but those unions were not the MLB Players Association.
Further, by virtue of the Players Association leadership, the players are well-versed in the history of solidarity. To that point, the public comments and reports to date seem to demonstrate that the players are prepared to remain strong in their collective defiance of the league’s proposals.
The 2027 season is in jeopardy. Many outcomes are possible, but the most likely seems to be this: After many missed games, the owners will take some additional financial concessions alongside their ever-increasing franchise values and give up on their attempt at a salary cap.
For now.
- Senior Counsel
He represents and advises businesses on a broad range of labor and employment matters, including discrimination complaints, wage and hour claims, class actions, employment agreements, restrictive covenants, data privacy ...
Also on Employment & Labor Insider
This is Constangy’s flagship law blog, founded in 2010 by Robin Shea, who is chief legal editor and a regular contributor. This nationally recognized blog also features posts from other Constangy attorneys in the areas of immigration, labor relations, and sports law, keeping HR professionals and employers informed about the latest legal trends.


